| 2020 | 2019 | 2018 | 2017 | 2016 | 2015 | 2014 | 2013 | 2012 | 2011 | 2010 |
| Novel |
| Jade City [Ciudad de Jade] , Fonda Lee. |
| The Changeling , Victor LaValle. |
| Novella |
| Passing Strange , Ellen Klages. |
| F | The Black Tides of Heaven , JY Yang. |
| F | In Calabria , Peter S. Beagle. |
| F | The Teardrop Method , Simon Avery. |
| F | Mapping the Interior , Stephen Graham Jones. |
| Short Fiction |
| The Birding: A Fairy Tale , Natalia Theodoridou. |
| Anthology |
| The New Voices of Fantasy , Peter S. Beagle & Jacob Weisman, eds.. |
| F | Black Feathers: Dark Avian Tales , Ellen Datlow, ed.. |
| F | The Book of Swords , Gardner Dozois, ed.. |
| F | The Djinn Falls in Love and Other Stories , Mahvesh Murad & Jared Shurin, eds.. |
| F | The Best of Subterranean , William Schafer, ed.. |
| Collection |
| The Emerald Circus , Jane Yolen. |
| Artist |
| Special Award [Professional] |
| Writing Madness , Patrick McGrath, Harry Brockway & Danel Olson. |
| F | Charles Coleman Finlay. [for editing F&SF] |
| F | Irene Gallo. [for art direction at Tor Books and Tor.com] |
| F | Greg Ketter. [for DreamHaven Books] |
| F | The New Annotated Frankenstein , Leslie S. Klinger. |
| Special Award [Non-Professional] |
| FIYAH , Justina Ireland & Troy L. Wiggins. |
| F | Ray Russell. |
| F | Podcastle , Khaalidah Muhammad-Ali & Jen R Albert. |
| F | Uncanny Magazine , Lynne M. Thomas & Michael Damian Thomas, eds.. |
| F | Beneath Ceaseless Skies , Scott H. Andrews, ed.. |
| Life Achievement |